Cantering in harness

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 22 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #39859
    jen judkins
    Participant

    I’m stealing this thread from the ‘driving demo’ thread, which is sort of in the throws of self-destructing at the moment;)

    My question is pretty simple…what is the role of cantering in harness? I have pretty extensive training with horses under saddle and one of the very clear training issues with youngsters is how to take them to higher speeds without them getting their adrenalin up so far they get into trouble. Generally, it is felt that by working them at speed, first the trot, then the canter and then faster, as they are able, they develope more and more ‘composure’ at speed. We are, after all, circumventing their natural instincts which tells them that the need to run has to do with danger….in essense developing ‘speed without fear’. I can see the value of this stradegy with driving and work horses, although wonder about the practical application. There appear to be relatively few instances where moving out at any speed would be an advantage, particularly faster than a working trot, but then I wonder if by avoiding speed in training, do you risk a serious bolting issue, if your team decides to kick it up for whatever reason? Appreciate any thoughts or feedback on this.

    Peanut comes home this weekend, so I’ll be taking over his day to day training.

    Thanks, jennifer.

    #47804
    Michael Colby
    Participant

    Whew. Thanks for rescuing this topic from the “other” thread (speaking of which, bravo to Carl for his thoughtful retort over there).

    For me, the topic of cantering in harness is all about the work that one is doing or is expecting from the horses wearing the harness. There is NOTHING I do with draft horses that calls for a canter. I log, do farm work, and give sleigh and hay wagon rides, none of which comes close to requiring the additional speed of a canter. Have my boys ever broken into a canter? Sure. My response? Bring ’em back to a trot unless I asked for the canter. Putting the bit in their mouths and the lines in my hands means I’m providing the guidance and, most importantly, making the critical decisions about direction and — yes — speed.

    But, who knows, maybe there’s a future out there for the NASCAR equivalent of wagon rides. It won’t be the first trend that has left me behind.;)

    #47806
    jen judkins
    Participant

    Mike, That makes sense to me…BUT I’m still struggling somewhat with the idea that our physical control over our horses despite bits and leverage have limits when it comes to a true bolting situation, where the horse(s) are truly scared and running. If you don’t somehow simulate that event and figure out how it will all end up, don’t you run the risk of simply having to ‘drive as fast as they can run’ until they come back? That might be pretty easy in a big field or a broad dirt road, but what about on a narrow alley or a rocky trail?

    I’m not generally a ‘what if’ type of person:rolleyes:, but I have a few patients in my practice who have had some serious injuries (nearly catastrophic) driving a cart. So while I’d like to believe it is as simple as you say, I know ‘it depends’. We don’t always have the control over our horses, we think we do. I have to admit, when I see Neil and his big hitch cantering around the field, I think, there’s someone who is prepared to go for a ride if need be. Lets face it, if you practice cantering a 1 or 2 or 8 (or 46) horse hitch often enough, don’t you prepare for that worst case scenario? Learn the skills necessary to ride out the widowmaker?

    Maybe it is indeed simply a leadership issue as you imply, but I’m not convinced. Are there risks to cantering in harness….like risk of injury from parts of the hitch to the horse? Jennifer.

    #47816
    Andrew Larson
    Participant

    Wow, I am already gaining lots of information and I just joined this site. I believe that there really aren’t many reasons for cantering either. But Neil’s demonstration on the video is a good reason in my opinion. I am sure there were quite a few people watching his hitch and had added enthusiasm about draft horses since they were going fast. This might cause them to go to more shows, pulls, demonstrations, and maybe even buy a team. This is all great added support for the rest of the draft horse world.

    I don’t have much experience in cantering teams, but I ride quarter horses a lot checking cattle and trailing them. I have trained a few youngsters and I never let them even trot until I had a couple of weeks riding. When I finally let them trot in a small pen they were fine, and then I did it out in the open(miles of Dakota Prairee). My dad always taught me that if they want to run away, then make them runaway. I don’t really believe to strongly in this and would never try it with a team, but that is what I did with each horse. Only one of them had the desire to runaway and I let him run(there was nothing that I could do anyway) but then when he started slowing down(two miles later) I gave him a little spur to show him that I was making him run and it wasn’t really his choice. I am just telling you about the experience.

    I like Jennifers point about the adrenaline. I guess that horses do generally run in fear and they do need to be trained out of it. It makes perfect sense why a horse tries to runaway sometimes when you begin to canter. I do think that it is a good idea to canter your team at some point in a safe situation when you think that your ready. Then when they do it in an unsafe situation for some unkown reason, they won’t be so scared of the new conditions.

    This is a beneficial discussion and has caused me to think about a lot of things that might save me some mishaps, Andrew

    #47805
    J-L
    Participant

    I don’t lope my teams around the ranch much either. I think you can get them used to it though. My last team of perch’s didn’t mind it when I’d break them into a lope with the bobsled chasing the moose out of the stackyards or hustling to beat the cattle to an open gate. BUT they were a good broke team and had done it enough to realize that sled wasn’t chasing them anywhere. I would not chase moose anywhere with my mules (sometimes they chase back). They don’t tolerate much cowboying. I really think it depends on the animals.

    Like Andrew said, you build up to speed or really anything new. Prepare for it and it’s usually not that bad. I break some teams and a bunch of riding horses and mules. The one thing I’ve learned over the years is that you put the time in training and it pays off no matter if it’s under saddle or in a harness.

    #47803
    Rod
    Participant

    Interesting posts. My ponys are used for both working and pleasure driving single and double. It the latter case i like them to move a little faster and make them trot. But it doesn’t seem to cause them to try and move out when I am working. They basically do what I tell them to do but I wonder am I building my self a problem by using them like that?

    #47799
    Carl Russell
    Moderator

    I don’t think that horses equate fear with running, as much as they may equate running with fear. In other words they charge around the pasture for a variety of reasons that have nothing to do with fear. Although they may be inclined to run when scared, consistent work interrupting that reflex will have its affect in any situation, and I think it is erroneous to assume that when they run they become scared.

    I can see how a person who was inclined toward the challenge would enjoy raising the energy level of the horses, and extending their skill level into new and more challenging experiences as a way to strengthen the working relationship.

    I personally have never had a reason at my level of enterprise to take my animals beyond a trot.

    That being said, I have had several instances where my horses were scared into running, and I was able to maintain the exercise of my initiative with them, even though they/we had never practiced it before.

    Once while spreading manure, one of my oxen pushed through a gate from an adjacent field because he became so excited by the activity that he needed to investigate, and the charge on the fence was low or something.
    He approached us at a gallop, and began dancing, throwing his head around and false charging.

    This was extremely unnerving to the off horse who was getting most of his attention. Even with this stimulus the horses stopped when I said whoa, and tried to stand, but the steer was wound up by then, and actually nearly hooking the mare.

    I knew that I could calm the steer if I got down, but the horses were justified in not trusting him enough to want to stay still for very long. However, they did remain standing until I felt the risk of physical contact was too high, and I spoke to them to move before they went on their own.

    They definitely wanted to run, but I kept them at a brisk walk turning away from the steer, until I was able to pull the lever for the beaters which finally was enough to distract the steer completely.

    After a few hundred feet without being chased, the horses resumed their normal demeanor, and when we reached the bar-way they waited calmly for me to close off that field so the steer wouldn’t follow us.

    It’s just one man’s experience.
    Carl

    #47807
    jen judkins
    Participant

    @Carl Russell 3233 wrote:

    I don’t think that horses equate fear with running, as much as they may equate running with fear. In other words they charge around the pasture for a variety of reasons that have nothing to do with fear. Although they may be inclined to run when scared, consistent work interrupting that reflex will have its affect in any situation, and I think it is erroneous to assume that when they run they become scared.

    I didn’t mean to imply that every horse experiences fear everytime they canter or gallop, lol! Just that it is common for a young horse to link the two together the first time or two and that it might be a good idea to plan that well in advance of the real deal.

    It may simply be that I am skewed in my experience too, as I work primarily with TBs and Arabs in my saddle work…much different breeds than most drafts. In fact, I had to laugh, Carl while reading your story about the steer. My arab cross would have killed himself and wrecked the hitch to vacate the premises in that situation. But again perhaps that is just my expectation of him, given what we have experienced together in the past.

    I beginning to realize how important our focus is in working closely with an animal…what we expect, what we want to happen, what we worry might happen…all play a role in outcomes. Some have said, they haven’t even thought about cantering their drafts in harness, so why would their horses even think about doing it? It may simply be a matter of intention.

    Good points as usual, Carl. Thanks. Jennifer.

    #47812
    dominiquer60
    Moderator

    I once saw John Lyons drive his App Stud at a demonstration. He borrowed the cart from some other folks, harnessed, hitched and drove like a pro, blinders and all (his horse happens to actually be blind). Everyone was wide eyed when he asked for a gallop and then a near sliding stop, he rolled back 180 and proceeded to lope figure eights with lead changes. It was a shock to many but his point was just because it is not asked for in competition doesn’t mean that it can’t be done. And some people enjoy the challenge of bringing their relationship with their animals to an out of the ordinary level.

    A friend of mine sent her mare away to train her to a cart, we had done the ground work and he was in charge of dealing with her fear of carts (a fear of which we did not create). When we got her back she would stand quietly to be hitched, had a whoa, walk, 3 speeds of trot and a canter. He taught all of his animals to canter in harness (world champion pleasure diving and harness racers alike). His goal was to make any mistakes easy to handle, like breaking to the canter in the show ring. If a horse broke they knew how to smoothly drop down a gear without a fuss and hopefully the judge was looking the other direction and never noticed.

    Perhaps these examples are not the best for use with draft animals but I can see the value in practicing the canter in harness, if you are inclined to do so. I can also see doing this for the drivers sake, especially when training the novice teamster. I can best relate to this via riding. When a novice rider is learning to ride a canter, this is a gait that the horse is comfortable with, but not the rider, it can be scary the first time, it is a whole different feel from the steady two beat trot. I know that it is scary for a novice driver to suddenly have the run away of the century and panic in such a new situation. It happened to me and I choked ahold of that poor horse and nearly flipped him over before he made an even stronger bolt into a tractor rut and launched me. He didn’t even run home, he ran at least a mile and a half through 3 fields until he ran so hard he bled from his nostrils. Perhaps if I had been more comfortable and balanced at a faster pace, we could have been able to steer around the rut and eventually slow down to a trot aways past the heifer barn (apparently cattle were a new thing for him). If I had the chance to practice I would try the canter in harness just so I was more comfortable with that sensation should the unfortunate runaway happen again.

    An alternative would be to get a position as a navigator on a combined driving marathon vehicle, that would take the spook out of me. Below are a couple of links for those with the time.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=viYUdEjVqTE&feature=related
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMlCbdEv94Y&feature=related

    Erika

    #47808
    jen judkins
    Participant

    Wow, thanks for the links, Erica! That looks like fun! If you can do that, I imagine there wouldn’t be too much trouble you could get into on the farm, huh?!

    Have you seen this one? As usual your links got me looking at a dozen more…but I have to get some work done now, lol! Jennifer

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qv0bt-3fo7A&NR=1

    #47813
    dominiquer60
    Moderator

    There is always trouble to get into, you just need to know where to look, but I would be a little better prepared if I could survive a marathon.

    Sometimes you hit a bump in the road.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NWWPw3x0E0g&feature=related

    And sometimes equipment fails.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d95WLQEERHw&feature=related

    So sometimes trouble finds you when you’re not looking for it and you least expect it.

    Sorry to those with dial-up, it a driving pair that hit a bump on a tight turn, tip the cart and run away. The other is a single horse who runs and kicks out of a failed breaststrap style harness, literally wiggles out and runs off with bridle and lines.

    Erika

    #47817
    Andrew Larson
    Participant

    There has been some more very good insight here. I do think that when you are cantering your horses there are a lot of different noises from the wagon and the harness probably feels different for the horse with everything moving around. These factors might instill a little fear in a team the first time they experience it. Andrew

    #47809
    jen judkins
    Participant

    Andy, any time you increase speed, you increase the volume of stimlus (or stimuli, I guess), so its like turning up the volume…some like it…some don’t.

    I think Erica’s point is valid…you don’t know you can be in trouble till you are. At that point, its important that you have some idea of how things ought to turn out….or have enough experience to know its not the end. I’m not there so I wonder alot about it, lol.:confused: Jennifer.

    #47800
    Carl Russell
    Moderator

    I was thinking a bit more about this. Although I never have the need to drive at high speed, I do engage a high energy forward gear when pulling heavy hitches of logs.

    As I thought about the concept of fear and energy level, it became a little clearer for me. I don’t think about my animals being scared. Yes I can see the nervous activity, but at it’s root it is adrenaline release, the fear may be real for them, but only until I show them there is nothing to fear.

    I can’t afford to wait until a particular situation, to interrupt, or condition a horse to the specific stimulus, so I am constantly conditioning them to de-escalate. Starting with a hoe in the barn cleaning manure, or at the water trough, if they jump or shy, then I work on it right then. Rather than letting them get numb to a situation, I want them to learn to come down from the heightened sense of response, right then, under my guidance. Sometimes I only make the smallest gain, but I follow a quote I heard years ago,(I think it was John Lyons) “Recognize the slightest tries”, and make a point that this is a lesson that they are learning from me.

    In this way, I never try to guess what stimulus I may need to expose them to, because I have them conditioned to follow my lead. First time the school bus goes whizzing by, yes they pay attention, but they pay more attention to me. Then when it comes to the hard pushing of heavy loads, when they have to raise their adrenaline level to a place in an experience where they have never been, I let them get fidgety and flighty, and work back down to a relaxed state.

    There are times when they can put on quite a show, but “so what, there’s nothing to be worried about” (my thoughts), and they know that I expect them to calm down. Eventually, we can turn on the adrenaline and turn it off without any fear.

    I know there are people who use the fear-adrenaline-run-power equation for pulling contests, but working horses on heavy loads in the woods, or on the farm, is quite different that on level ground in a pulling ring, and there needs to be control. The photo that Jason posted on the gallery recently shows that very well. There is a team that is putting all they can into that effort, and there’s a very relaxed teamster (JR) just letting them do it. They have all been through that transition together many times.

    I run into a certain mind-set among people with animals that they need to train them to do certain things, or accustom them to certain situations. I realize that it is a convention, and it obviously works, but I also believe that a successful communication process can be established that will transcend any situation, even a really scary completely new experience. It is also fundamental to actually performing work, because there are times when you just have to do something for the first time, and your expectations for completion need to be high.

    So as little use as I have for cantering horses in harness, and a preference for practical application, I can see how the exercise has similarities to things I do with my horses.

    Carl

    #47814
    OldKat
    Participant

    @Carl Russell 3259 wrote:

    I was thinking a bit more about this. Although I never have the need to drive at high speed, I do engage a high energy forward gear when pulling heavy hitches of logs.

    As I thought about the concept of fear and energy level, it became a little clearer for me. I don’t think about my animals being scared. Yes I can see the nervous activity, but at it’s root it is adrenaline release, the fear may be real for them, but only until I show them there is nothing to fear.

    I can’t afford to wait until a particular situation, to interrupt, or condition a horse to the specific stimulus, so I am constantly conditioning them to de-escalate. Starting with a hoe in the barn cleaning manure, or at the water trough, if they jump or shy, then I work on it right then. Rather than letting them get numb to a situation, I want them to learn to come down from the heightened sense of response, right then, under my guidance. Sometimes I only make the smallest gain, but I follow a quote I heard years ago,(I think it was John Lyons) “Recognize the slightest tries”, and make a point that this is a lesson that they are learning from me.

    In this way, I never try to guess what stimulus I may need to expose them to, because I have them conditioned to follow my lead. First time the school bus goes whizzing by, yes they pay attention, but they pay more attention to me. Then when it comes to the hard pushing of heavy loads, when they have to raise their adrenaline level to a place in an experience where they have never been, I let them get fidgety and flighty, and work back down to a relaxed state.

    There are times when they can put on quite a show, but “so what, there’s nothing to be worried about” (my thoughts), and they know that I expect them to calm down. Eventually, we can turn on the adrenaline and turn it off without any fear.

    I know there are people who use the fear-adrenaline-run-power equation for pulling contests, but working horses on heavy loads in the woods, or on the farm, is quite different that on level ground in a pulling ring, and there needs to be control. The photo that Jason posted on the gallery recently shows that very well. There is a team that is putting all they can into that effort, and there’s a very relaxed teamster (JR) just letting them do it. They have all been through that transition together many times.

    I run into a certain mind-set among people with animals that they need to train them to do certain things, or accustom them to certain situations. I realize that it is a convention, and it obviously works, but I also believe that a successful communication process can be established that will transcend any situation, even a really scary completely new experience. It is also fundamental to actually performing work, because there are times when you just have to do something for the first time, and your expectations for completion need to be high.

    So as little use as I have for cantering horses in harness, and a preference for practical application, I can see how the exercise has similarities to things I do with my horses.

    Carl

    … what Carl is saying here. I sort of take the same view. My issue is that I DON”T work my horses for a living, so I have to fit in harness time as I can. I have decided to actually SCHEDULE into my day the time I want to spend down at “The Horselot” as we call it.

    While I don’t try to figure out what stimulus to expose them to (in Carl’s words) I do try to take advantage of the free resources that are right under my nose to give them a broader exposure to real world situations. Let me explain what I mean by that.

    We live in a town of about 4,000 people. While there is no ordinance against keeping horses in town, ours are about .6 of a mile to the east of our home (which is in a residential neighborhood). I bought a few acres about ten years ago that just happens to be on the street that bounds the city limits & this is “home” for the horses. This property is about .4 of a mile north of the junior high & .6 of a mile from the high school. Cattle pasture in between. This means traffic is frequently heavy coming and going to these schools.

    School buses, boys (and some girls) gunning their engines as they zip by … nothing seems to faze the horses as they graze. From there it is just a small step to getting them out on the road as this traffic passes. They don’t seem to notice it. Far different situation than when they first came down from Red Deer, Alberta, Canada. EVERYTHING rattled them then. I also can drive them down to the high school as the band practices out beside the football stadium. Plenty of sights and sounds that they won’t see in the round pen.

    To the east of the lot maybe 1/2 mile is a city owned baseball / soccer facility. I haven’t taken them down there when the kids are playing, but there is an access road on the back side that looks to be the perfect place to make them work while the chaos of youth sports goes on around them. The great thing is that it is fenced off from the park, so I won’t have to worry about the children getting “too close”. Only a block further east is a US highway & a railroad track. While most people would prefer not to expose their animals to these sights and sounds, I look at them (within reason) as a free education for the girls. As long as the experience is positive and the situation is something I can control, I welcome these opportunities to work in a different environment. There are other examples I could cite, but I think you get the picture.

    If we were working several hours a day to a full day like Carl and some of the others on this site do I wouldn’t even consider the need to do the things I mentioned. In my situation it is a reaonable alternative.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 22 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.