DAPNET Forums Archive › Forums › The Front Porch › Off Topic Discussion › Get Big or Get Out, worse case senario
- This topic has 32 replies, 16 voices, and was last updated 14 years, 10 months ago by jac.
- AuthorPosts
- January 23, 2010 at 2:28 pm #41339dominiquer60Moderator
http://www.cbs6albany.com/video/?videoId=62945588001&lineupId=&play=now
I just learned from home that a diary farmer, Dean Peirson, shot 51 of his cows and then turned the gun on himself. A note was left on the door “don’t come in, just call the cops.”
The news said that he was despondent about personal issues, but I wonder how much was influenced by the get big or get out problems surrounding “modern” agriculture. I can imagine that not making enough to cover your costs of production can get to a farmer in at bad way. Top that with not wanting to go into debt, or further debt or not being able to borrow because your lender doesn’t put value on your farm. Perhaps I am completely off base here, maybe Dean was on the edge any way, but the current dairy situation and the attitudes of production agriculture could not have helped any.
This news is all over the regional, national and international media, I can only hope that those that influence change are paying attention. NYS state is considering a new Farm Labor Bill, that will dramatically change farm labor in NY, it negatively impacts farmer directly and employees indierctly, yet it is supposed make life better for everyone. I think that they need to take a look at more than just the labor bill, because if it passed as committee suggests, that there are going to be a lot more Dean Peirsons out there taking matters into their own hands. I am not saying what he did was wrong, just that if they want what is best for farmers, their employees and to avoid such messy situations, than some smart decision making needs to happen. If Laborers deserve more overtime and time off, than so do the farmers themselves.
Remember, be supportive of your farm neighbors, you don’t have to agree on how to farm, but rather that it is important to farm.
Erika
January 23, 2010 at 6:01 pm #57194near horseParticipantI’m really sorry to see this happen.
January 23, 2010 at 6:50 pm #57216jacParticipantWe can only guess at the anguish this poor man went through. Unfortunatly suicide rates seem disproportionatly high in the agricultural sector and modern pressures are bound to play a part. In our thoughts.
JohnJanuary 23, 2010 at 7:48 pm #57187Carl RussellModeratorAhh Geez, what a tragedy. I can’t even imagine the state of mind he was in. That is a lot of work. For his sake I hope it makes the statement he wanted to get across.
:(:confused::mad:
Carl
January 23, 2010 at 9:13 pm #57205lancekParticipantYou know what really gets me is why the American public allows cooperate america to get away with this If we are smart enough to put a man on the moon why are we not smart enough to figure out that we are paying more in interest than the actual thing we bought! Or that our live should not be governed by a credit score. You would think they would wake up and do something about it and don’t say there is nothing you can do because if everybody just kept our money in our pocket for one week didn’t pay there bills and told cooperate america that unless they changed there ways they wouldn’t get anything than I think they would change there minds !!!!! 😡
January 23, 2010 at 10:56 pm #57192PatrickParticipant@lancek 14805 wrote:
You know what really gets me is why the American public allows cooperate america to get away with this If we are smart enough to put a man on the moon why are we not smart enough to figure out that we are paying more in interest than the actual thing we bought! Or that our live should not be governed by a credit score. You would think they would wake up and do something about it and don’t say there is nothing you can do because if everybody just kept our money in our pocket for one week didn’t pay there bills and told cooperate america that unless they changed there ways they wouldn’t get anything than I think they would change there minds !!!!! 😡
Exactly. The USDA is at fault too. Once upon a time, they supported the small family farm, now all of it’s policies are geared toward big ag. Try to be a small time poultry breeder in the face of a depopulation. You won’t stand a chance. Or a 4H kid with a steer trying to resist premises ID and tracking.
I’ve never lived during the times when a small diversified family farm could make a living with a few dozen head of cows, or only a thousand layers, and USDA and big ag have ensured that I probably never will.
January 23, 2010 at 11:19 pm #57197dominiquer60ModeratorPatrick,
You can make a living on a small scale, you just have to be smarter than the USDA and Ag schools. I know a guy with 12 cows that makes cheese, a gardener with 2 acres and so on. You just need to adjust your standards of living, marketing strategies and budget well with what little you make. If there is a will there is a way. Of course the less responsibilities you have the easier it is to do this, I wouldn’t expect most to do such, just saying that it is possible.
At the place that I call home they make a living on 40 beef, 2500 layers and a lot of hay and vegetables. In the future I sense that there will be a shift to less animals, and the addition of animal power, but this family has been making it work for 70 years and 3 generations. The saving grace of course is that they own everything debt free with the exception of one truck and tractor and those loans are only taken to increase credit score and line of credit, other wise they would have been paid for already.
Erika
Picture caption: Good diverse small farms still exist, we just need more of them.
January 24, 2010 at 1:30 am #57211brigleParticipantThis is a tragedy for him and his family and friends. I think your right you can make it on the small farm. The thing that needs to happen is the American farmer big and small and the American people need to tell the federal government to get out of our business. If we are going to ask them to get out of our business we need to ALL stop taking the hand outs (subsidies) (grants) and any other.We built this country on our own lets go back to that. Every time I hear somebody is trying something new the next thing out of their mouth is how the gov. is subsidiesing their project. I dont know if I will ever see this but I hope I do for my children and grandchildren.
January 24, 2010 at 10:57 am #57209mother katherineParticipantDominiquer
Where are you in NY? We’re in Otsego county.
On the dairyman – that’s a tragedy. We have a young family up the hill trying to live on dairying, and it’s next to impossible. He and she work shoulder to shoulder, quit their off farm jobs, and are good, decent people. The milk prices, thanks to big biz, are killing them. Another young dairyman near us is slowly sinking under a mound of debt: poor milk prices and no off farm job. He sells hay to try and make a few bucks. We recently started doing hay business with another youngish couple: same deal. These are all farms about the size of Pierson’s: around 50 milkers.
My heart bleeds for these people just trying to live and raise families against all odds.
oxnunJanuary 24, 2010 at 3:43 pm #57186Gabe AyersKeymasterIt is interesting that this sad situation made the national news and aired on our local news last night. The only comment after the death of the cattle and farmer was reported was that “he had personal issues”, as Erika suggested in her post.
The pisser with that is the dismissal of the situation missing that it may/must have much greater meaning than his “personal issues”. It is like a potentially huge statement being hidden under a dismissive conclusion by media and therefore the authorities, whichever comes first to the viewers mind, the line is blurred…
There is probably a much greater story than his personal issues and even if the personal issues are the same as all the pressures we know are being applied to small producers it shouldn’t be minimized by media. Hopefully someone will do more investigation into this mans life situation and try to understand what was going on in the overall picture of his life. Of course that story probably won’t get air time nationally, but it would interesting that it all be studied for the public good.
I don’t want to dwell on the negative but would be interested in knowing more about what Mr. Pierson was going through, his “personal issues”.
People seem to be doing unbelievable stuff all over the country/world and the details of why they are doing these things are important, just not suitable to the shallow sound bite portrayals that may reflect the depth of the general public’s attention span.
I agree with the posters that say you can make it as a small farmer. I have done it for over thirty years and it leads me to the comment that comes to mind when someone asks –
“How you doing man?”, my answer often is “Surviving! and I feel like I am bragging when I say that”, because what we are doing with our lives as small farmers and small loggers is extremely difficult and if you play the game against the stacked deck of the status quo cards dealt, you are likely going to loose.
So participate within your own place in the economy and community and create your own markets when you can and live modestly, cheaply. Keep your inputs low, don’t buy anything you don’t need and work as much as your body will allow and your heart and mind will inspire.
I am not going to bash the USDA as I have borrowed from them for almost thirty years. I am not involved at a level at this point the requires the reporting and baloney of the older programs, but still do service a loan that has more interest in the annual payment than principle, but I am glad to have this piece of land and the freedom to live as I wish. This is still the land of opportunity. The land of reasonably fertile soils, lush and productive forests and some humans around that actually are neighbors, not just folks that live close by.
Make the most of it as you can. If you get to the point you feel like acting out as Mr. Peirson did, get help because neither you or your animals can clearly make a commonly understandable statement in a violent death. The dominant paradigm will just sweep you under the rug with a dismissive comment like you have “personal issues”. I am sad for him and the farming community at large, as someone else posted here, the suicide rate among farmers is alarming. But there is no fire drill exercised for the lost leader segment of our society, that is spent to insure that food is cheap, so the ignorant masses/consumers can eat nutrition-less food that makes them fat while they set on the couch and watch tv that is trying to sell the stuff they don’t need, as they head back to meaningless jobs soon to be replaced by computerized robots. Modern life does reek of personal misery issues.
It is like the joke about modern times – The problem with being a part of the rat race, is that even if you win, you are still a rat.
Carry on dear farm friends from all over, stay small, stay sane and humane.
I am not one to speak to this in a holier than thou sense, or earthyier than thou – I get down sometimes too. But I also still get excited by the new patches on my overalls or how much manure I have collected so far this winter or how big that one mare’s belly is getting – so take this with a grain of salt, remembering though, that salt is a necessary element to a horses survival…. whatever that means and everything means something….
Anyone else feeling mad and sad about this?
This is a personal post and has nothing to do with HHFF or my signature that is automatically posted at the end of every post here….
~
January 24, 2010 at 5:23 pm #57198dominiquer60ModeratorJust a couple more points of interest.
This happened either Thursday or very early Friday when the footage was taken on my link. The large dozer and excavator in the shots are the neighbors burying the dead cows. It didn’t make the news until Saturday morning, and only one of the 4 local news channels aired it then. If a pitbull had been found abused or a politican found unfaithful to his wife it would be on every channel and they would be fighting for the best video footage, but only one station thought it news worthy after the fact. What does this say about our society?
That we value companion animals and sex scandals over the stewards of our land that have the potential to once again provide all the food that this nation NEEDS (we don’t need fresh tomatoes in March, but even that is possible without importing). It really just makes me sick, and I feel fortunate that there is a group like this that at least understands my frustrations with the deeper meaning of this suicide.
Another interesting fact was brought up by our market friends that went to Maine on a maple production tour. Apparently there have been at least 5 farmer/dairy suicides there already. So apparently you need to take the ship down (your herd) with you to make a national blip on the radar. I have know two people to exit life by there own hands. My beloved elderly neighbor, who didn’t want to be a burden, and the local feed store owner, who I assume didn’t want to loose his independence. In the end I think that they are the same thing, just worded differently, they make the last choice, therefore maintaining their independence.
I simply wish that the other 99+% saw this act as a red flag against the failing system that I/we see it as, and not just “personal issues.”
Erika
January 24, 2010 at 6:37 pm #57202Joshua KingsleyParticipantAs I read all the posts and reflect on the current status in agricultural policies I wonder what it really would take to make an impact on the national level.
It is a sad commentary on our current world condition when we can spend billions in bailing out the big businesses and yet the price of milk is set by the government a year ahead of time! With the current system the American dairy will be hard pressed to stay afloat in the coming years. All in the name of “cheap” food. Unfortunately the public has not seen the truth in the agriculture to economy link since the great depression. The modern policies were established then to help get the economy stimulated, with little or no provision for the future.Just some humble thoughts on our current state of dairy in the USA.
Joshua
January 24, 2010 at 7:43 pm #57217jacParticipantThe media has a lot to answer to. When the Amish community was devastated by that gunman the British media could only come up with crappy comments like “they live in the dark ages” or ” a secret sect” and most hurtful of all was the ” incest that went on in their community”.. like mainstream folk are perfect. I have no acess to what has been reported stateside but I can guess at the disregard for the man and the attention grabbing headlines. It seems to be a worldwide thing, the belittling of the agricultural sector.
JohnJanuary 25, 2010 at 3:43 pm #57199dominiquer60ModeratorA local rural paper ran a better article about Dean Pierson that did more justice to the circumstances that may have added to his personal issues. http://www.thedailymail.net/articles/2010/01/24/news/doc4b5cde4aef7c7397804009.txt
Also today at the noon hour Northeast Public Radio WAMC will run a story about Dean and the dairy industry as well. There is likely to be a quote from a non-dairy farmer discussing the importance of infrastructure and services that the dairy industry creates and how vital it is to all other farmers, and that if dairy fails we will not be able to support all these other businesses and farming would get much tougher for us.
I find some comfort knowing that thousands of people listening to 18 stations will be challenged to think that there may have been significant factors beyond his control behind Mr. Pierson’s “personal issues.”
Erika
January 25, 2010 at 5:31 pm #57200dominiquer60ModeratorIt would be nice to see more reporters with the mind to bring such aspects of farming to to public eye. Thanks to Susan Barnett who was on the job long before I emailed her yesterday afternoon.
http://www.publicbroadcasting.net/wamc/news.newsmain?action=article&ARTICLE_ID=1603626
- AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.