I don’t have a Homesteader to compare to, but I do love my McD Cultivator. If you really want a nice cultivator, refurbished McCormick Deerings can be purchased for ~$1,200, and new (all quality after market parts) for ~$1,800. Though there are still old timers in great shape that can occasionally be found for a deal, it is nice to know that a quality tool plus replacement parts can be found in York County PA. Crossroads Cultivators (717) 927-1697.